2025 Preakness Stakes Preview: Expert’s Top Horse Picks and Odds Revealed

The 2025 Preakness Stakes is set to be an electrifying event within the U.S. Triple Crown series, unfolding at Pimlico Race Course on May 17, 2025. This milestone 150th running encapsulates the drama, unpredictability, and strategic complexity that have come to define this prestigious horse race. By dissecting the field composition, key withdrawals, frontrunners, expert insights, odds dynamics, and historical trends, a clear narrative emerges about the race’s potential outcomes and broader significance.

A Snapshot of the 2025 Field and Race Essentials

The Preakness Stakes traditionally serves as the second segment of the Triple Crown, bridging the Kentucky Derby and Belmont Stakes. This year’s field presents a compact but competitive group of nine horses, blending proven Derby performers with fresh challengers eager to make their mark. Starting at precisely 7:01 p.m. Eastern Time during the Pimlico race card’s 13th race, stakes are high, and anticipation palpable.

The structure of this race offers a fascinating tactical puzzle. Pimlico’s dirt track is known for its quirks, favoring horses that can adapt to its specific pace and positioning challenges. The impact of race order (13th on the card) also means that horses and jockeys must maintain focus amidst a long day of racing.

The Ripple Effect of Sovereignty’s Withdrawal

One of the defining twists heading into the 2025 Preakness is the withdrawal of Sovereignty, initially the early favorite at 8-5 odds. This horse’s decision to forgo the race for recovery shakes up both competitive dynamics and wagering landscapes. The removal of such a strong contender recalibrates the field by opening front-runner opportunities and forcing bettors, trainers, and jockeys to rethink strategies.

Sovereignty’s absence not only introduces uncertainty but also highlights the physical demands placed on elite racehorses navigating the Triple Crown trail. This decision reflects a tactical choice prioritizing long-term performance and health over immediate glory, a microcosm of industry-wide challenges in managing equine athletes.

Front-Runners and Key Contenders—Shifting Dynamics

With Sovereignty out, Journalism emerges as the clear 8-5 favorite. This Kentucky Derby runner-up is poised to capitalize on his near-victory experience and familiarity with high-stakes racing. The narrative of redemption adds a compelling emotional layer to his campaign, inspiring both fans and bettors.

Other noteworthy contenders include Sandman and American, both of whom showed strength in the Derby and carry competitive odds (Sandman at about 4-1). Their inclusion balances the field with a blend of consistency and potential surprise outcomes. Meanwhile, horses like Clever Again and Rodriguez bring seasoned trainers and jockeys into the fray, enriching the tactical dimensions. Rodriguez, in particular, has attracted expert attention for his odds and team strengths, signaling he should not be overlooked despite less fanfare.

Expert Insight Illuminates Betting Trends

Jody Demling, widely respected for his sharp Preakness analyses, offers invaluable foresight. His record—accurately selecting half of the last 20 winners and perfect trifectas recently—affirms the weight his predictions carry in the betting community. Demling’s approach considers a mosaic of factors: past race results, training developments, jockey expertise, and race day conditions, emphasizing the importance of nuanced assessment beyond superficial odds.

Demling advises bettors to remain watchful of last-minute shifts in horse fitness and evolving odds, underscoring the fluidity of handicapping in the lead-up to race day. This prudent optimism blends respect for data with acknowledgment of horse racing’s inherent unpredictability, helping fans engage with the event both analytically and emotionally.

Decoding the Odds and Futures Market

Morning line odds reveal a fairly open contest. Journalism’s positioning as favorite at 8-5 aligns with expectations grounded in recent performances. Meanwhile, Sandman’s 4-1 odds and River Thames’ approximately 9-2 standing indicate perceived potential but also wager caution. The 6-1 odds assigned to Goal Oriented reflect a dark horse possibility—an on-paper outsider with the capability to dent favorites’ ambitions.

Evaluating these odds requires integrating performance metrics with Pimlico’s unique conditions. Post position, track surface, and pace scenarios complicate pure form analysis, pushing informed bettors toward multifactor strategies that combine speed figures, jockey track records, and post-race recovery signs.

Historical Patterns Cast Light on Present Uncertainties

The recurring phenomenon of a Kentucky Derby winner skipping the Preakness is particularly pronounced this year, marking the fourth such instance in seven recent Triple Crown seasons. This pattern disrupts traditional narratives, challenging bettor expectations and demonstrating that the Preakness can serve as an independent proving ground, not merely a sequel to the Derby.

Such unpredictability enhances the race’s allure by spotlighting emerging talents and altering wagering landscapes. The absence of dominant horses often transforms the Preakness into a stage for dynamic storylines, underdog triumphs, and unexpected tactical masterstrokes.

Anticipating the Drama: A Race Beyond the Finish Line

The 2025 Preakness Stakes transcends mere competition—its 150th anniversary enshrines it as a storied tradition of resilience, strategy, and passion. The interplay of key withdrawals, expert forecasts, and shifting odds ensures that spectators and bettors will experience a rollercoaster of emotional and intellectual engagement.

Journalism’s quest for redemption amidst an unsettled field embodies the spirit of persistence. The strategic depth brought by experienced trainers and jockeys amplifies the contest’s intrigue, while the unpredictable rhythms of Pimlico’s track promise excitement until the final furlong.

In sum, the 2025 Preakness Stakes will be remembered not solely for who crosses the finish first, but for the narrative threads woven through preparation, withdrawal, tactical adaptation, and betting drama. It exemplifies why horse racing remains a captivating blend of athleticism, strategy, and storytelling—an enduring spectacle inviting all to witness the powerful convergence of horse and human endeavor.